A combined 35 football players from cross-street rivals Henderson State and Ouachita Baptist earned All-Great American Conference honors when the league released its 2026 postseason awards on Wednesday.
Ouachita landed 20 selections—including seven first-team picks—while Henderson State had 15 players recognized across the three all-conference teams for the second consecutive year. Both Arkadelphia programs also placed 23 student-athletes on the GAC Academic Honor Roll and produced one GAC Elite Scholar Athlete apiece.
All-GAC First Team
Ouachita placed seven Tigers on the first team, highlighted by senior return specialist Carter McElhany, who earned two total All-GAC honors this season to bring his career total to seven. McElhany became the first player in GAC history to record four career kickoff return touchdowns—highlighted by an 87-yard score against Arkansas-Monticello—while also earning second-team recognition at wide receiver after becoming the seventh Tiger to surpass 2,000 career receiving yards.
Joining McElhany on the first team for Ouachita:
- Chris Henley, Jr. (RB, Grad.): A two-time GAC Offensive Player of the Week this season who rushed for 842 yards (6.2 yards per carry) and 15 total touchdowns.
- Isaiah Simpson (OL, So.) & Wyatt Payne (OL, Jr.): Anchored a Tiger offensive line that ranked second in the GAC in scoring offense and third in rushing.
- Justin Crutchmer (LB, Jr.): Earned his second straight first-team nod after ranking 10th in the league with 75 tackles (7.5 per game), alongside 8.5 tackles for loss, 2.5 sacks, six pass breakups, and three forced fumbles.
- Elijah Mason (S, So.): Ranked third on the Tigers with 48 tackles and added an interception.
- Dante Thomas (S, Grad.): Tallied 38 tackles and three forced fumbles during the regular season.
Henderson State had three players named to the first team:
- Maddox Davis (WR, Fr.): The Benton native earned his first first-team selection after leading the Reddies and ranking second in the GAC with 931 receiving yards on 69 catches, tying for the league lead with seven receiving touchdowns.
- Jerrale Powers (TE, Sr.): Led all conference tight ends with 473 yards on 40 receptions and five touchdowns,including a seven-catch, 83-yard, two-touchdown outing against Ouachita.
- Ryan McDonnell (K, Fifth-Year): Connected on 12 of 17 field goals—including a 48-yarder against Southern Nazarene—and booted 42 touchbacks on 69 kickoffs.
All-GAC Second Team
Henderson State placed five players on the second team, anchored by veteran offensive linemen Gabe Hernandez(center, Sr.) and Clement Ulale (tackle, Sr.), who helped power a Reddie attack that led the conference in passing and ranked third in scoring. Sophomore tight end/fullback Knox Pilgreen also earned second-team honors as a lead blocker and pass catcher (four catches, 37 yards). Defensively, sophomore linebacker/defensive back Leo Morris (36 tackles, six pass breakups, two fumble recoveries) and freshman defensive back James Koslosky (12 tackles, three pass breakups) rounded out the Reddies’ second-team picks.
Ouachita added four second-team selections:
- Tre Nichols (QB, So.): Ranked third in the GAC in total offense with 1,812 passing yards (15 TDs) and 764 rushing yards (12 TDs).
- Carter McElhany (WR, Sr.): Reached the 2,000-yard career milestone on a 39-yard touchdown catch in the Battle of the Ravine victory over Henderson State.
- Bo Baker (WR, Sr.): Earned his third career All-GAC selection as a key receiver and kickoff return threat.
- Eli Wilson (OL, Sr.): Helped pave the way for Ouachita’s top-three rushing and scoring units.
All-GAC Third Team
Ouachita led the way with 10 third-team honorees, heavily featuring its defensive front:
- Offense: Sophomore wide receiver Eli Holmes-Holt, who caught a touchdown in five of the final six games to tie for the GAC lead with seven receiving scores.
- Defense: Defensive linemen Romelo Bell (35 tackles, 6 TFL, 3 sacks), Cortavion McMillan (36 tackles, 6.5 TFL,3.5 sacks), Joey Ortego (25 tackles, 4 TFL, two fumble recoveries), and Danny Johnson (19 tackles, 5.5 TFL); sophomore linebacker Kahlil Smith (70 tackles, team-high 10.5 TFL, 4 sacks, two defensive TDs); sophomore cornerback KJ Colen (44 tackles, team-high seven pass breakups, two interceptions); and graduate safety Kris Robinson (45 tackles, six pass breakups, one blocked kick).
- Special Teams: Redshirt freshman kicker Braden Johnson (6-of-8 FGs, 48-of-50 PATs) and sophomore special teams specialist Jonathan Blake.
Henderson State had seven players named to the third team:
- Offense: Fifth-year quarterback Austin Ledbetter (1,998 passing yards, 14 TDs, 4 INTs, and a league-leading 184.5 efficiency rating in eight games), senior running back Chris Gannaway (team-high 473 rushing yards, 7 TDs), and senior wide receiver Mike Jones (31 catches, 540 yards, 3 TDs).
- Defense: Senior defensive end Mulumba wa-Kalonji (40 tackles, 7 TFL, 4.5 sacks, three forced fumbles), fifth-year defensive tackle Ryan Vollmer (37 tackles, 2.5 TFL), and sophomore linebacker Jackson Byerley (41 tackles,5.5 TFL, two fumble recoveries).
- Special Teams: Junior return specialist Taylin Paskel, who ranked third in the GAC in punt return yardage (137 yards on 16 returns) alongside 562 kickoff return yards.
Academic Honors
Out of just 13 players across the entire conference named GAC Elite Scholar Athletes—awarded to student-athletes maintaining a 4.0 cumulative GPA with at least 70 credit hours completed—two hail from Arkadelphia: Henderson State defensive end Mulumba wa-Kalonji and Ouachita junior punter Owen Tomlinson (finance major).
Both schools also placed 23 players on the GAC Academic Honor Roll, recognizing student-athletes with at least a 3.5 GPA and one full year of college residency.
Discover more from
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
