How a dangerous insect affected the cattle market; research finds implications for ag policy

SMALL INSECT, HUGE PROBLEM — The New World Screwworm halted cattle imports into the U.S. and had some implications for policymakers. | Shutterstock image

By MARY HIGHTOWER | University of Arkansas Division of Agriculture

Fast Facts 

  • Researchers build on framework examining row crop basis
  • Basis effects felt the most farthest from the border 

Effects from the stoppage of cattle imports from Mexico due of New World Screwworm had some surprising effects on cattle basis in the United States and implications for policymakers, researchers found. 

Basis is the difference between the cash price of a commodity and the futures price.  

In 2024, the U.S. began the first of three border closures to livestock movement from Mexico when New World Screwworm — a pest that can be fatal to mammals — was found in Mexico after a decadeslong absence.  

While the move was meant to stem the spread of the insect, “Mexican cattle are an important source of the U.S. feeder cattle supply and closing the border represents a major supply shock,” said James Mitchell, associate director of extension for the Fryar Price Risk Management Center of Excellence and co-author of the research.

Cattle port closures 

Cattle ports at the Mexican border were initially closed November 2024, with additional restrictions added in May 2025. The U.S. Department of Agriculture had announced plans for a phased reopening in July 2025, but the ports remained closed and USDA added renewed restrictions on July 9 due to continued northward movement of the pest. 

In 2026, USDA’s Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service reopened the cattle port at Douglas, Arizona, on Aug. 24. The port at Santa Teresa, New Mexico, was reopened Sept. 24, and Columbus, New Mexico, was reopened Oct. 26. The port at Nogales, Arizona, is scheduled to be reopened Nov. 30. 

Finding out just how much of a supply shock these closures represented was the goal for researchers Mackenzie Gill, assistant professor of agricultural and resource economics at the University of Tennessee, Jada Thompson and Mitchell. Thompson, an associate professor specializing in poultry economics, and Mitchell, an associate professor specializing in livestock economics, work for both the University of Arkansas Division of Agriculture and the Dale Bumpers College of Agricultural, Food and Life Sciences.  

“We find that feeder cattle basis strengthened following the closure,” Gill said. “The magnitude of this effect depends on a market’s proximity to the border and the duration of the closure.”  

The researchers said that the results indicate that markets nearer to the border didn’t always experience the greatest upward pressure on cattle basis. It was the farthest ring of the ripple effect that saw the biggest impact. 

“That was contrary to our expectations, with peak effects occurring around 350 miles from the border,” Mitchell said.  

He said they found that “the effect really matters for markets close to the border but dies out quickly in time.”  

“I was also surprised by how few markets report prices close to the border. This created a data problem for us,” he said. 

Consumers and communities 

While the supply of cattle coming from south of the border is large enough to make the U.S. a net importer of live cattle, the screwworm-related border closures probably aren’t a major factor for consumers.  

“In a normal year, the U.S. imports more than a million head of cattle from Mexico,” Mitchell said. “When those cattle can’t cross the border, it limits an already tight supply of cattle in the United States. That can eventually contribute to higher beef prices.  

“However, there are a lot of factors that determine what consumers pay for beef, and I wouldn’t say New World Screwworm is the main one,” he said.  

For the communities that surround the livestock ports of entry, the effects go deeper than market effects, Mitchell said.  

“This matters a lot for areas close to the border that feed cattle,” he said. “There are some Texas feedlots that specialize in importing and feeding Mexican cattle.  

“There is evidence that some of those feedlots closed,” Mitchell said. “Same for ports of entry. Without Mexican cattle there really isn’t work for those folks.”    

Policy and industry implications 

The research provides the industry more insight into the workings of cattle markets. 

“What the results do is showcase how large policies to protect a broader industry can have high costs in certain markets or to some participants, even if the total cost is more mitigated when looking on average,” Thompson said. “The border closures helped to protect all livestock producers, but the financial impact was concentrated.  

“I think the decay function we modeled was super interesting because it characterized how those concentrated costs diffuse with distance,” she said.  

“Taken together, these findings underscore the complex and multifaceted nature of trade policy disruptions stemming from animal disease events,” said Gill. “Policymakers should be aware that the costs of border closures are not evenly distributed across space or time, with certain markets more vulnerable due to both proximity and evolving perceptions of disease risk.” 

“While biosecurity and eradication measures remain essential, understanding these effects can improve policy design and help anticipate when and where market disruptions may be most severe,” said Mitchell. “Similarly, these findings may help policymakers understand which markets may be most impactful to the beef industry as phased border reopening strategies are being crafted. 

“I think one of the biggest takeaways is national cattle prices or average prices don’t always tell the whole story,” Mitchell said. “When something like New World Screwworm disrupts cattle trade with Mexico, the impacts can differ depending on where you’re located.  

“For producers, feedlots, and others buying and selling cattle, understanding those regional price relationships is important for marketing decisions and managing price risk,” he said. “It’s also useful for understanding how changes in trade policy can affect local cattle markets.” 

Building price risk insights from a proven framework

The team built their work on a framework borrowed from an analysis that Mitchell completed with fellow UADA agricultural economist Hunter Biram on the Mississippi River and soybean basis. 

“It’s the same logic. An event happens that impacts prices, but the price impact dissipates, or decays, spatially as you move farther away from where the disruption occurs,” Mitchell said. 

“I think this framework has applications well beyond cattle markets,” he said. “Any time you have a disruption that affects the movement of agricultural commodities, whether it’s a disease outbreak, transportation problem, or trade restriction, you can use a similar approach to examine how the impacts differ across locations.” 

Mitchell said he and Thompson have worked together to carve out a niche for the University of Arkansas and the Division of Agriculture as institutions known for addressing the market and policy implications of livestock and poultry diseases.  

“We both knew when New World Screwworm was first detected in the fall of 2024 that this would be an event with significant market and policy implications,” he said. “Gill was working with Thompson as a post doc when we started the project but has since joined the University of Tennessee. She really took the idea and ran with it.”  

Their research, “Heterogeneous spatio‐temporal effects of the Screwworm‐induced border closure on US cattle basis,” was published Nov. 5, 2026, in the Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics Association.  


Discover more from

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.